11044-17 vs 11500-32 — Compare
Seymour Duncan Antiquity 2 Single Coil Pickup For P-Bass vs Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
These are entirely different instruments: the Antiquity 2 is a replacement pickup for precision bass guitars, while the SA-3XL Woody is a soundhole pickup for acoustic guitars. Choose the Antiquity 2 if you're upgrading a P-bass tone; choose the SA-3XL if you need to amplify an acoustic guitar.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan Antiquity 2 Single Coil Pickup For P-Bass
Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan Antiquity 2 Single Coil Pickup For P-Bass | Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $109.00 | $99.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Pickup Type | Any Position | Any Position |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan Antiquity 2 Single Coil Pickup For P-Bass
- ✓ Authentic vintage P-bass character with warm, woody low end
- ✓ Hand-built with period-correct Alnico 5 magnets and plain enamel wire
- ✓ Balanced output and noise-free performance across all dynamics
- ✓ Suits classic rock, blues, funk, and studio work
Why choose Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
- ✓ Hum-canceling stacked-coil design eliminates noise in live and studio settings
- ✓ Individually adjustable pole pieces for precise string-to-string balance
- ✓ Includes 14-foot studio-quality cable for immediate use
- ✓ Compact wood-housed design maintains natural acoustic character
Frequently asked questions
Can I use either pickup on my guitar or bass?
No. The Antiquity 2 is a magnetic replacement pickup designed specifically for precision bass guitars and installs inside the bass body. The SA-3XL is a soundhole pickup for acoustic guitars only and will not fit or function on a bass.
Which pickup requires more technical skill to install?
The Antiquity 2 requires soldering and routing expertise or professional installation. The SA-3XL simply drops into an acoustic soundhole (94-100mm diameter) and plugs in via the included 1/4" connector, making it accessible to beginners.
Do either of these pickups need batteries or external power?
No. Both are fully passive magnetic pickups with no battery requirement. The Antiquity 2 produces its own signal through coil design; the SA-3XL uses a stacked-coil hum-canceling design without active electronics.
What genres suit each pickup?
The Antiquity 2 excels in classic rock, blues, funk, and vintage-focused studio work. The SA-3XL is designed for acoustic guitar amplification across any genre—live performance, studio recording, and home use—and is not suitable for electric instruments.