11101-05-B vs 11500-32 — Compare
Seymour Duncan SH-1b '59 Model Black Pickup vs Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
The SH-1b '59 is a bridge humbucker for electric guitars designed for blues and classic rock, while the SA-3XL Woody is a soundhole pickup for acoustic guitars built for live performance and recording. Choose the '59 if you need a vintage-voiced electric guitar pickup; choose the Woody if you're amplifying an acoustic guitar without adding electronics inside the instrument.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan SH-1b '59 Model Black Pickup | Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $99.00 | $99.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Pickup Type | — | Any Position |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan SH-1b '59 Model Black Pickup
- ✓ Warm, articulate tone perfect for blues, classic rock, and hard rock styles
- ✓ Hand-built in USA with Alnico V magnet and proven vintage character
- ✓ Balanced 8.1kΩ resistance works well for both lead and rhythm playing
- ✓ Vacuum wax potted construction ensures long-term reliability
Why choose Seymour Duncan SA-3XL Woody HCTM Hum-Canceling Acoustic Pickup
- ✓ Hum-canceling design eliminates 60Hz noise common in acoustic pickups
- ✓ Adjustable pole pieces let you balance tone across different string gauges
- ✓ Wood housing preserves acoustic character while amplifying naturally
- ✓ 14-foot studio-quality cable included; works with any standard amp input
Frequently asked questions
Can I use either of these on the same guitar?
No. The SH-1b '59 is a humbucker designed to replace the bridge pickup in an electric guitar's pickup cavity. The SA-3XL Woody fits into an acoustic guitar's soundhole. They are not compatible with the same instrument.
Which one is better for metal or high-gain tones?
Neither is ideal for metal. The SH-1b '59 excels in blues and classic rock with natural compression and articulate highs; Seymour Duncan lists it as not ideal for metal or djent. The SA-3XL is designed for acoustic instruments and cannot be used on electric guitars for amplification.
Do either require batteries or external power?
Both are fully passive—no batteries or external power needed. The SH-1b '59 uses a simple 2-conductor wire connection. The SA-3XL connects via a standard 1/4" male plug to any amplifier.
Which suits a beginner player?
The SA-3XL supports beginners through professionals and works on any acoustic guitar within its soundhole range. The SH-1b '59 is rated for intermediate, advanced, and professional players, so it's better suited to someone with established technique and tone preferences.