11103-66-MBc vs 11208-04 — Compare
Seymour Duncan Holcomb Scourge TB Black Cover Pickup vs Seymour Duncan Humbucker STL-1S Vintage Broadcaster Lead Pickup For Tele
The Holcomb Scourge TB is a high-output metal pickup (77.0 dB) with treble-forward voicing for saturated, articulate gain tones, while the STL-1b is a vintage-voiced humbucker (7.6k ohms) optimized for blues and classic rock with balanced dynamics. Choose the Scourge for aggressive modern metal; choose the STL-1b for blues, country, and vintage rock tones.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan Holcomb Scourge TB Black Cover Pickup
Seymour Duncan Humbucker STL-1S Vintage Broadcaster Lead Pickup For Tele
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan Holcomb Scourge TB Black Cover Pickup | Seymour Duncan Humbucker STL-1S Vintage Broadcaster Lead Pickup For Tele | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $175.00 | $178.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Pickup Type | — | Neck |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan Holcomb Scourge TB Black Cover Pickup
- ✓ High output (77.0 dB) cuts through dense, high-gain mixes
- ✓ Extended treble presence (8.5) maintains clarity in distortion
- ✓ Trembucker format fits standard humbucker cavities
- ✓ 4-conductor wiring enables coil-taps and splits
Why choose Seymour Duncan Humbucker STL-1S Vintage Broadcaster Lead Pickup For Tele
- ✓ Vintage Alnico 5 character preserves dynamics and string articulation
- ✓ Lower DC resistance (7.6k ohms) retains responsive touch sensitivity
- ✓ Designed specifically for Telecaster bridge mounting
- ✓ Balanced output suits blues, country, and classic rock without harshness
Frequently asked questions
Can the STL-1b handle distortion and gain?
The STL-1b is voiced for blues and classic rock dynamics; its 7.6k ohm resistance and Alnico 5 magnet preserve string definition but lack the high output (77.0 dB vs. typical vintage 6–7k range) needed for modern metal saturation. It excels in moderate overdrive, not heavy djent or metal.
Will the Holcomb Scourge TB work in a Telecaster?
The Scourge is a Trembucker (53mm humbucker format) designed for humbucker cavities. Standard Telecasters have single-coil cavities, so routing or a different pickup is required. The STL-1b is explicitly built for Telecaster bridge mounting.
What's the key tone difference?
The Scourge prioritizes treble presence (8.5 treble EQ) and punchy mids (4.5) for cutting through gain; the STL-1b balances treble articulation with vintage character and sustain, relying on lower output and Alnico 5 for dynamics rather than aggression.
Which is better for intermediate players?
Both suit intermediate players. The STL-1b is more forgiving for touch and dynamics in traditional styles; the Scourge demands a high-gain amp and technique suited to metal. Choose based on genre and rig, not skill alone.