EMG5340 vs EMG5417 — Compare
EMG HBCS Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in White vs EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black
The HBCS is a drop-in 4-string pickup focused on warm low-end tone, while the P5A is a complete 5-string system with onboard preamp controls and tone shaping. Choose the HBCS if you need a simple replacement pickup for a 4-string bass; choose the P5A if you play 5-string or want integrated volume and tone adjustment at the pickup.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
EMG HBCS Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in White
EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black
Specs side by side
| EMG HBCS Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in White | EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $115.00 | $115.00 |
| Brand | EMG Pickups | EMG Pickups |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose EMG HBCS Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in White
- ✓ Fits standard 4-string bass cavities with P-style winding and humbucker housing
- ✓ 3000-hour battery life (roughly 4 months) with minimal power draw
- ✓ Quik-Connect solderless installation—no wiring expertise needed
- ✓ Warm, deep low-end response with controlled articulation
Why choose EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black
- ✓ Designed specifically for 5-string basses with proper string coverage
- ✓ Integrated 25K volume and tone potentiometers for on-pickup control
- ✓ Alnico V magnets provide warm, well-defined tone with natural sustain
- ✓ Complete wiring harness included—ready to install out of the box
Frequently asked questions
Which pickup works with 5-string basses?
Only the P5A is designed for 5-string instruments. The HBCS is engineered for 4-string basses with a maximum string width of 2.10 inches.
Do these pickups include tone and volume controls?
The P5A includes integrated 25K volume and tone potentiometers built into the pickup system. The HBCS is a passive signal delivery pickup without onboard controls; tone shaping would require external preamp or amp settings.
What's the magnet difference and does it matter?
The HBCS uses ceramic and steel magnets for deep, warm lows with punch. The P5A uses Alnico V magnets for a more refined, articulate tone with natural sustain. Ceramic typically emphasizes low-end presence; Alnico V offers more balanced clarity across frequencies.
How much soldering or wiring knowledge do I need?
The HBCS uses EMG's Quik-Connect system for tool-free, solderless installation and battery swaps. The P5A ships with a complete harness but assumes you can handle standard wiring or have professional installation available.