EMG5417 vs EMG5428 — Compare
EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black vs EMG 35DC Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in Red
The P5A is a five-string-specific active pickup with Alnico V magnets delivering warm articulation, while the 35DC is a four-string humbucker with ceramic magnets engineered for noise-free studio clarity. Choose the P5A if you play five-string bass and want warmth; choose the 35DC if you play four-string and prioritize studio precision and low noise.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black
EMG 35DC Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in Red
Specs side by side
| EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black | EMG 35DC Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in Red | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $115.00 | $115.00 |
| Brand | EMG Pickups | EMG Pickups |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Black
- ✓ Designed specifically for 5-string bass instruments
- ✓ Alnico V magnets provide warm, natural sustain
- ✓ Runs on standard 9V battery
- ✓ Articulate, punchy tone ideal for funk and progressive styles
Why choose EMG 35DC Active Humbucker Bass Pickup in Red
- ✓ Ultra low-noise preamp critical for studio recording
- ✓ Compact soapbar form factor fits standard 4-string cavities without routing
- ✓ 18V power option extends dynamic range and headroom
- ✓ Tight low end with minimal coloration for clean definition
Frequently asked questions
What's the main difference in string count compatibility?
The P5A is engineered for five-string bass instruments with appropriate cavity dimensions and magnet placement. The 35DC is designed for four-string bass only, with a maximum string width of 2.50 inches.
How do the magnet types affect tone?
The P5A uses Alnico V magnets, which deliver warmth, definition, and natural sustain. The 35DC uses ceramic bar magnets in a parallel humbucker configuration, providing a noise-free, minimal-coloration response better suited to tight, controlled low-end reproduction.
Which is better for studio recording?
The 35DC is engineered specifically for studio work with an ultra low-noise preamp and 18V power recommendation to maximize headroom and transient clarity. The P5A is versatile for both studio and live but prioritizes punchy articulation over noise rejection.
What are the power supply differences?
The P5A operates on a standard 9V battery. The 35DC recommends 18V power supply to achieve extended dynamic range, though it includes a 25K battery bus for flexibility.