EMG6517 vs EMG6520 — Compare
EMG P5 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red vs EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red
Both are budget-friendly active P5 pickups for five-string bass with identical resonant frequency and battery efficiency, but they differ in magnet type and output noise. The P5 uses ceramic magnets for maximum punch and high output (4.50V thump), while the P5A uses Alnico V magnets with a split-coil design for warmer articulation and cleaner noise performance (-99 dBV vs -106 dB). Choose the P5 for aggressive modern funk needing maximum headroom; choose the P5A if noise floor and midrange definition matter more.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Specs side by side
| EMG P5 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red | EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $119.00 | $119.00 |
| Brand | EMG Pickups | EMG Pickups |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose EMG P5 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red
- ✓ Ceramic magnets deliver aggressive punch and high output headroom
- ✓ 4.50V thump mode maximum output for dynamic range
- ✓ Optimized for cutting through dense mixes with forward presence
Why choose EMG P5A 5-String Active Bass Pickup in Red
- ✓ Alnico V magnets provide warmer, more musical articulation
- ✓ Superior noise performance at -99 dBV ensures cleaner signal
- ✓ Split-coil design enhances defined mids without harshness
Frequently asked questions
What's the practical difference in noise between these two?
The P5A has -99 dBV noise floor versus the P5's -106 dB specification, meaning the P5A is quieter in real-world electrical environments. This matters more in recording studios and silent venues; the difference is negligible on loud stages.
Which one has higher output?
Both reach 4.50V in thump mode. The P5 outputs 2.00V in finger/thumb position while the P5A outputs 1.00V in string mode, making the P5 slightly hotter for general playing dynamics.
Are installation and battery life identical?
Yes—both include solderless wiring, draw 80 microamps at 9V, support up to 27V DC, and offer 3000-hour battery life. The only differences are tone character and noise specs.
Which works better for modern funk?
Both are listed for funk. The P5 excels with raw punch and aggression; the P5A suits funk that prioritizes articulate lows and defined mids without excessive sizzle, making it slightly more versatile across subgenres.